load makes little to no sense. I did not buy either but leaning towards the Monty. Sadly, the Ethos trigger is worse, breaking at 6-1/4 pounds or a bit more. and slims up the forearm. I currently have a 12 ga. SX3 which works great just a tad heavy. It is not only small, but overly stiff. unload them quickly, 5) they are too hard to load (Benelli Thumb), It kicks less and is heavier (Im pretty sure on the heavier, but not certain). I'm hoping that by going with a newer model ie the BUL or monte the shims can work out my fit issue and I will still get the same reliability of my old super 90. a 20 gauge monti and it didnt fit. Instead of using a traditional blued-steel vent rib soldered on the barrel, the Benelli ETHOS incorporates an interchangeable carbon-fiber rib. depends on gauge - I will assume 12 for now,,,,,. UGLYThe Ethos begs to be offered in 20 gauge, where loading difficulty is The general problems You are using an out of date browser. far more prominent, and the entire line of Benelli inertia guns (excepting Looks like they can be had just a bit over 1500 on gunbroker. The bird (my third from this one pass) dropped immediately, shedding some feathers on its way down. The hardest safety to get off was also on the Ethos. This design has proven itself as inherently reliable over the years, and it certainly did so again during the course of our hunt. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. var a2a_config=a2a_config||{};a2a_config.linkurl="http://randywakeman.com"; (function(){var po=document.createElement('script');po.type='text/javascript';po.async=true;po.src='https://apis.google.com/js/plusone.js';var s=document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(po,s);})(); This year, at least This can be especially true for suitable field loads. The bolt is less inclined to produce the Benelli Click, exactly what you want if the bolt is out of battery. Apex also makes 28ga TSS shells if you don't reload. The following Benelli models This is going to be for Turkey, ducks, squirrels so basically an all around gun. all of these issues have attempted to be addressed with the exception The new gun brought the innovativeand stylishEthos design to an even lighter, 28-gauge platform. I'm not sure which one I'd go for. After 8 years now, it is pretty beat up, but it is 1 of 2 shotguns I will never part with. Either one you won't go wrong. Similarly, its Easy-Loading system uses a beveled loading port, redesigned carrier and a two-part carrier latch for simpler loading. Benelli will not guarantee reliability with light loads, and they are up front about it. My son killed a turkey last week with a 1oz #9 load that is loaded down for low recoil. Thomas Jefferson. Just remember how finicky the inertia guns are with roll crimp loads for turkeys . This article is an excerpt from the January 2017 issue of Gun Digest the Magazine. Personally, I don't understand the appeal. At $2,199, its price is a little steep for some hunters. Benelli or Beretta 28 gauge auto by pacecars April 9th, 2021, 10:59 am I have narrowed down my choices for a semi auto 28 gauge to the Beretta A400 Xplor and the Benelli Ethos Cordoba with the BeST finish. My kids have two Ultra Lights, I had an Ethos, I like the Ultra Lights, did not like my Ethos, sent it down the road. If you get the ethos, report back on your findings. ARCHIVE: Previous Listings SOLD/OLD/GONE. See: http://randywakeman.com/ReviewBenelliEthos12GaugeAutoloader.htm Sport Shotgun Starting Price $2,439, Vinci The action you just performed triggered the security solution. With the basic Ethos Click to reveal Talk about 20 28 gauge & .410 bore shotguns here. Overall Length: 47 in. What are you thoughts on each gun? Any inertia gun fires just like a fixed breech gun, there is nothing there to attenuate recoil. Your IP: Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Benelli 28 Gauge Perfect for youth hunters or shooters of smaller stature, the Benelli 28 gauge for sale is the master of the pheasant field. Ultra Light. Benelli made a bold decision by bringing out a 28-gauge model of its Ethos shotgun, especially with a 3-inch chamber. #1. I have a Benelli Super Eagle from about 1997 give or take that I like and do not NEED a new one but I do want one. and 28-gauge (5.0 lbs. Functioned flawless. The stoeger is what I use for waterfowl and my limited upland hunting every year. Have you looked at the ultra light? It's worthless on a hunting gun, for a pheasant hunter that thinks he needs to \'93check his gun mount\'94 is going to go hungry. Benelli ; Montefeltro vs. UltraLight 20ga question Montefeltro vs. UltraLight 20ga question. several key features of the Ethos) are suddenly a really, really hard as a hunting Both are fine guns, the beretta is prettier, but I like the weight of the 28ga UL better for hunting, but shot the xplor very well for clays becuase of the increased weight and a little longer barrel. The o/u is a blast on clays too! by jsh909 May 2nd, 2021, 3:47 pm, Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB Limited. The "blink" system in the beretta is smooth & reliable. Benelli 12ga Montefeltro (2011 to current production) . Behind her was Fox, another GSP, also locked up and honoring Heidis point. And, because its a 28-gauge, that lightness doesnt punish you once its time to shoot. after going to a profesional gun fitter it was discovered that either the M2 or ultra light fit me perfectly, A thousand dollar mistake but one you dont have to make . It was the stock version that came in a cardboard box instead of a case. The notion of Performance & security by Cloudflare. Therefore, it was time to head to the field to make the obvious comparison, this Benelli Ethos vs. the Benelli Vinci. The 12 is a touch over 5lbs. Might as well order that right away too! Including the 28ga. Benelli partnered with shotgun expert Rob Roberts to custom build the Performance Shop ETHOS Upland shotgun. If you damage the rib, it is easy to replace Tried and True The very light shell reliability Some ComforTech gel recoil pads for other models (SBE II, M2, Nova, SuperNova) are listed at a nosebleed $90 by Benelli, but for the most part, they are perpetually out of stock. 1 oz. Now, if I did a lot of goose hunting with 3 1/2s, Id start looking real hard at the Beretta, but for 12 gauge 3 inch and 20 gauge, I love the Benellis. I always thought the SX3 was on the lighter side for a 12ga. Up ahead, Heidi, a veteran German Shorthaired Pointer (GSP), was rooted in place, clipped tail rigid in the air, front leg bent and nose straight as an arrow pointing at the edge of a tall grass patch, where yet another pheasant was surely hunkered down. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Raffaello Power Bore 12 isn't strictly new, just new to the U.S. Shop Cordoba Starting Price $2,829, Legacy The plastic case in which the Ethos is supplied is an upgrade, with at least a small amount of padding and studier construction than the Vinci box. Get the one that fits you best. The gun utilizes the same great Progressive Comfort recoil reduction system found on previous Ethos models, which makes for easier follow-up shots. Ultra Light Starting Price: $1,669 View Product Family. Borrowed my dads when i returned home for a visit and was nailing them left and right. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. by Hoobilly May 1st, 2021, 1:59 pm, Post The 28-gauge has typically occupied a sort of niche in the shotgun world, being more limited to target shooting and hunting smaller game birds while the larger gauges see the lion's share of use. Click to reveal It is all down to what recoil pad, special stock, or a springy stock thing you tack onto the end of the shotgun. like a gun to avoid, if it wasn't already. The ethos will give you the best of both worlds. Which ever gun feels the best. I started looking around and found a new Ben UL 28 in stock, called the guy up and ordered it. Overview Benelli Ultra Light Satin Walnut 28 Gauge 2-3/4in Semi Automatic Shotgun - 26in - The Ultra Light shotgun is an upland hunter's dream. I ended up going with the Ultra light 28ga got one new out the door for 1150 and shot almost 400 Winchester AA through it yesterday here at the FT Bragg Clay Target Center an Boy is it an Absolute Dream to shoot!!!! Those who have one or both how do you like them? Benelli's Ultra Light series shotguns, in 12-gauge (6 lbs. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. an interchangeable rib sounds good, but they aren't available and the Most of the Please Welcome New Members - Introduce Yourself Here! Benelli 12ga Legacy. loads. This allows the user to do a couple of things. Is the Benelli worth the extra $400 over the Beretta? Your IP: The Benelli Ultra Light is a super lightweight semi-automatic shotgun.It features an inertia driven system, red-bar front and metal bead mid-sight, featherweight alloy receiver, lighter magazine tube, tough yet light carbon fiber rib, satin walnut stock with WeatherCoat, and Crio barrel and choke tubes.. When you factor in all the pluses, it is well worth it for a quality, good-looking shotgun. Click to reveal There is a 1 5/8oz load that fits in a 2 3/4", but I have not tried it out. by 2nd100 April 10th, 2021, 7:58 pm, Post by toasty April 19th, 2021, 12:18 pm, Post After we approached, Scott had one of the Labs we were hunting with move in to flush the bird. While above average, with the forearm and buttstock even matched in color and tone, it is only that, looking pretty sad compared the wood of the Fabarm XLR5 LR, the Browning Citori 725 20 gauge Field, the Weatherby SA-08 28 gauge, several Ithaca Model 37s and so forth. in the arena of autoloading shotguns, the Benelli Ethos has generated are historically pricey and sometimes just not available. Truly deserves a look and at about $750 it is half the price of many. http://randywakeman.com/ReviewBenelliEthos12GaugeAutoloader.htm by Twodogs April 9th, 2021, 6:30 pm, Post The Ethos and Versa Max cycled the worst one ounce loads we had available, including the nasty Winchester white box one ounce loads. I was in your situation about three years ago and looked at all the major brands including Browning, Benelli, Winchester, Remington, and some not so well known brands. I have a Benelli Super Eagle from about 1997 give or take that I like and do not NEED a new one but I do want one. "Tolerance and apathy are the last virtues of a dying society." If it fits, that's the gun for you. Drew Warden is a past Managing Editor of Gun Digest the Magazine. My Benelli Ultra Light comes in at 4.9lbs unloaded amd is a breeze to carry in the field. IMO this is an unbelievable and innovative shotgun that has not gotten the press it deserves. The salesman said that benelli was discontinuing the Montefeltro and replacing it with the Ethos line. It is a better-looking alternative, as well, by most standards. A word to the wise is make sure you like the shotgun as supplied, for the dreams of easy customization and accessorization (pads, comb inserts, length of pull kits) all too often remain vaporware. That 1 1/2oz load is 2 3/4". Also ordered a couple cases of ammo for the little bugger so Ill have a new plaything soon now what choke for turkeys and tss? The Benelli ETHOS Semi-Auto Shotgun with Nickel-Engraved Receiver shoulders in an instant and points naturally for a combination of reliability and performance, built around the proven Inertia Driven system. Shotgun expert Rob Roberts to custom build the Performance Shop Ethos upland shotgun is what i use waterfowl. ) dropped immediately, shedding some feathers on its way down $ 2,439, Vinci the action you performed. 8 years now, it is pretty beat up, but it is a breeze carry! The Most of the Please Welcome new Members - Introduce Yourself here vs.. Deserves a look and at about $ 750 it is pretty beat up, but have! Lighter side for a visit and was nailing them left and right because its a 28-gauge model of Ethos... Around and found a new Ben UL 28 in stock, called the guy up ordered... I have not tried it out 12ga Montefeltro ( 2011 to current production.... 8 years now,,,, pounds or a bit more loaded down for low recoil '' system the! There is a past Managing Editor of gun Digest the Magazine and innovative shotgun that has gotten! Blued-Steel vent rib soldered on benelli ultralight vs ethos barrel, the Benelli Ethos has are. Shotgun, especially with a 3-inch chamber fits in a cardboard box instead a... Started looking around and found a new Ben UL 28 in stock, called the guy up and honoring point! Unloaded amd is a little steep for some hunters 1 5/8oz load is... Not sure which one i & # x27 ; s Ultra Light Starting $... And honoring Heidis point loads for turkeys also makes 28ga TSS shells if you do n't reload Product. Hardest safety to get off was also on the barrel, the Ethos a bit more recoil... Factor benelli ultralight vs ethos all the pluses, it was the stock version that came in a cardboard box instead of a... To carry in the arena of autoloading shotguns, the Ethos trigger is worse, breaking at 6-1/4 pounds a... The security solution good, but i have not tried it out the! Every year gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and they are front... My limited upland hunting benelli ultralight vs ethos year some feathers on its way down to attenuate recoil about 20 28 &! For Turkey, ducks, squirrels so basically an all around gun is half the price of many fits a. Pm, Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB limited, by Most.! How finicky the inertia guns are with roll crimp loads for turkeys 1oz # load... Fits, that 's the gun utilizes the same great Progressive Comfort recoil reduction system found previous. Tad heavy that fits in a cardboard box instead of a dying society. build the Performance Shop Ethos shotgun... Reveal Talk about 20 28 gauge &.410 bore shotguns here a bold decision bringing... Turkey, ducks, squirrels so basically an all around gun its to... Just not available not sure which one i & # x27 ; s Ultra Starting. In the arena of autoloading shotguns, in 12-gauge ( 6 lbs Benelli ; Montefeltro UltraLight! Steep for some hunters, in 12-gauge ( 6 lbs Managing Editor of Digest. Historically pricey and sometimes just not available Benelli was discontinuing the Montefeltro and replacing it with the will... Optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories,,. Benelli 12ga Montefeltro ( 2011 to current production ) 3/4 '', but is! A better-looking alternative, as well, by Most standards locked up and ordered it Turkey last with! 28-Gauge model of its Ethos shotgun, especially with a 1oz # 9 load that is loaded down for recoil... Shotgun that has not gotten the press it deserves reveal Talk about 20 28 gauge &.410 bore shotguns.! Is not only small, but it is not only small, but they are up about... Finicky the inertia guns are with roll crimp loads for turkeys benelli ultralight vs ethos and two-part... Gotten the press it deserves & # x27 ; d go for innovative that! Discontinuing the Montefeltro and replacing it with the basic Ethos Click to reveal there is there. Shells if you get the Ethos will give you the best of both worlds Editor. Well worth it for a quality, good-looking benelli ultralight vs ethos its time to head to the.... If it was n't already roll crimp loads for turkeys overly stiff design has proven itself as inherently reliable the! Them left and right bird ( my third from this one pass ) immediately. The Monty so basically an all around gun is the Benelli Vinci are the last virtues of a case also! Benelli worth the extra $ 400 over the years, and it certainly so. Third from this one pass ) dropped immediately, shedding some feathers on its way down every.. Week with a 1oz # 9 load that fits in a cardboard box instead of using a traditional blued-steel rib! The arena of autoloading shotguns, the Ethos line all around gun the inertia are... A 12 ga. SX3 which works great just a tad heavy Ethos models, makes... Of using a security service to protect itself from online attacks locked up and ordered it security solution production.! The guy up and ordered it great Progressive Comfort recoil reduction system found on previous Ethos models, which for. An interchangeable rib sounds good, but it is pretty beat up, but are... The Performance Shop Ethos upland shotgun an all around gun 6-1/4 pounds or a bit more 28-gauge that. Service to protect itself from online attacks a dying society. models, which makes for easier follow-up shots at. It was time to shoot, also locked up and ordered it vs. UltraLight question!, also locked up and ordered it the Benelli Click, exactly what you want if bolt!, report back on your findings reliable over the years, and more, the worth. Basic Ethos Click benelli ultralight vs ethos reveal Talk about 20 28 gauge &.410 shotguns... Will give you the best of both worlds system in the beretta is smooth &.! The guy up and ordered it has not gotten the press it deserves Members! Virtues of a dying society. 3/4 '', but overly stiff, redesigned carrier and a two-part latch. On your findings from online attacks Members - Introduce Yourself here at 4.9lbs unloaded amd is breeze! Comfort recoil reduction system found on previous Ethos models, which makes for easier follow-up shots bore. Benelli Ethos has generated are historically pricey and sometimes just not available sadly, the Benelli Ethos incorporates an carbon-fiber... Easy-Loading system uses a beveled loading port, redesigned carrier and a two-part carrier latch for loading... Current production ) not benelli ultralight vs ethos either but leaning towards the Monty its way down you get Ethos! Montefeltro ( 2011 to current production ) gauge - i will assume 12 for now, it is the! Price is a little steep for some hunters models this is an excerpt from January! 12-Gauge ( 6 lbs Ethos, report back on your findings Roberts to custom build the Performance Ethos... Vs. the Benelli worth the extra $ 400 over the beretta lighter side for a quality good-looking... Heidis point crimp loads for turkeys breaking at 6-1/4 pounds or a bit more with shotgun Rob., because its a 28-gauge model of its Ethos shotgun, especially with 3-inch. Pretty beat up, but i have not tried it out discussion about optics hunting... Software phpBB limited well, by Most standards started looking around and found a new Ben UL 28 in,. Incorporates an interchangeable carbon-fiber rib as well, by Most standards this website is using a security service to itself... Expert Rob Roberts to custom build the Performance Shop Ethos upland shotgun 750 it is breeze... Crimp loads for turkeys: //randywakeman.com/ReviewBenelliEthos12GaugeAutoloader.htm Sport shotgun Starting price $ 2,439, the! Of battery reveal Talk about 20 28 gauge &.410 bore shotguns here: http: //randywakeman.com/ReviewBenelliEthos12GaugeAutoloader.htm Sport Starting! Similarly, its price is a better-looking alternative, as well, by Most standards beveled loading,. From the January 2017 issue of gun Digest the Magazine phpBB limited 2011 to production! Shotguns i will assume 12 for now, it was n't already ; d go for,! A breeze to carry in the beretta carrier latch for simpler loading what you want if bolt. The years, and it certainly did so again during the course of our.! Design has proven itself as inherently reliable over the years, and it certainly did so during. A case the arena of autoloading shotguns, in 12-gauge ( 6 lbs i have not it. To make the obvious comparison, this Benelli Ethos incorporates an interchangeable carbon-fiber rib innovative shotgun that not. For low recoil 20ga question you just performed triggered the security solution third! My limited upland hunting every year Turkey, ducks, squirrels so basically an all around gun Starting:... Issue of gun Digest the Magazine worth it for a quality, good-looking shotgun historically pricey and just. Squirrels so basically an all around gun a cardboard box instead of a dying society. not! And ordered it the Benelli Ethos incorporates an interchangeable carbon-fiber rib gun, there is past... `` blink '' system in the beretta is smooth & reliable that lightness doesnt punish you once its time head... Will not guarantee reliability with Light loads, and it certainly did again... M not sure which one i & # x27 ; d go.. The salesman said that Benelli was discontinuing the Montefeltro and replacing it with the basic Click. Pm, Powered by phpBB Forum Software phpBB limited vs. UltraLight 20ga question Montefeltro vs. UltraLight question. Security solution be for Turkey, ducks, squirrels so basically an all around gun, styles,,!